← All resources

Human review / 4 min read

A gate needs an owner.

A release decision needs a criterion, evidence, and someone responsible for the call.

FlakeMap research note / Synthetic example / 8 October 2026

Agree before you test

The engineering owner defines the task artifact and the acceptable failure condition with the QA champion. Define what a meaningful regression would look like.

Review the exception

A reviewer compares the observed artifact with the criterion, records a rationale, and keeps unresolved evidence visible. The prototype only changes a mock state.

Validate incremental value

Compare the readout with the existing eval stack. Advance the study only when a meaningful missed regression is independently confirmed and an engineering lead commits a real gate or funded trial.

Order lookupPO-204
Stock checkTimeout injected
PO draftRetry + late response
↳Two paths reach draft creation.Candidate lacks a shared deduplication guard.
Inspect the example